English-language news for internationals in Denmark

‘Moral Failure’: Refugees Welcome’s Founder Criticises Rwanda Plan

Denmark and four other European countries want to send failed asylum seekers to a centre in Rwanda from 2027. A leading refugee advocate calls the plan a moral failure and says Rwanda’s past should rule it out.

On Monday this week, Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen of the Social Democrats (Socialdemokratiet) announced a joint effort with four other countries to work towards an agreement in early 2027 to establish a deportation centre in Rwanda.

The Danish Dispatch has spoken with Michala Clante Bendixen, founder and head of Refugees Welcome, about these plans. Bendixen suggests they represent a “moral failure”.

Bendixen also suggests that weak human rights in Rwanda and past experiences with the country mean that the Danish government will not be able to ensure the safety of people sent to Rwanda from Denmark.

What is the plan?

The plan would see Denmark, Germany, Austria, the Netherlands, and Greece share a deportation centre in Rwanda with room for about 100 people at a time. The plans are for the first deportations to Rwanda to take place by the end of 2027.

There, the countries would be able to send failed asylum applicants who cannot otherwise be deported from their countries for various reasons, most significantly because their home countries, or the people themselves, do not cooperate.

In Rwanda, according to the plans, people will be offered the choice to integrate and work in Rwanda, return to their home country, or find a third country to move to.

This is not the same plan that both Denmark and the UK have previously floated, which would have seen asylum applicants stay in Rwanda while their application is processed.

“Moral failure”

While Frederiksen celebrated the plans, Michala Bendixen has a very different view on sending failed asylum seekers to Rwanda.

She told The Danish Dispatch: “I think the whole mindset of this whole situation, the whole discussion, is a moral failure.”

She added: “On one hand we say we respect the European Convention on Human Rights, and we respect the UN Convention on Refugees, and we actually determine people’s asylum cases in a very thorough and detailed way.

“But on the other hand, we do everything to prevent them from asking for asylum. We make sure that there are no legal and safe ways to apply for asylum.”

The Ministry of Immigration and Integration did not respond to The Danish Dispatch’s request for comment.

Rwanda’s human rights record

Bendixen also added that she did not think Rwanda’s human rights record lived up to standards that would make it defensible for Denmark to send failed asylum applicants there.

She noted, “We should not leave people in Rwanda’s custody, so to speak, because it’s going to be a disaster. They will probably disappear.”

To back up her point, she pointed to a previous example: “Rwanda has tried this before with Israel and the Eritrean and Sudanese refugees who were deported to Rwanda back then, around 10 years ago, they ended up in Libya, in the desert and on the Mediterranean.”

Israel never had an official agreement with Rwanda, and Rwanda says the scheme was abandoned. However, international outlets such as the BBC have covered the arrangement suggesting roughly 4,000 people were sent from Israel to Rwanda and Uganda.

Bendixen also pointed to another episode: “Not many years ago there was a riot among refugees who wanted to have better food rations. According to Human Rights Watch, 12 people were shot to death.”

Rwandan police said five refugees died in the 2018 shooting and that officers had been attacked, but Human Rights Watch’s report puts the toll at at least 12.

The Rwandan government was contacted by The Danish Dispatch but did not respond.

“Brainwashed”

Aside from the Social Democrats, Bendixen also criticised the other parties in the government, especially the Social Liberals (Radikale Venstre), who have previously been very opposed to an agreement with Rwanda, but now support it.

Bendixen said of the party, “They’re using exactly the same phrases as Mette Frederiksen when they try to defend it.

“So she has kind of brainwashed them to believe that this is a great idea and that this will stop dangerous journeys over the Mediterranean.”

The Social Liberals did not respond to The Danish Dispatch’s request for comment.

“Not about sending people back”

At a press conference in Vienna on Monday, Frederiksen explained that the agreement “is not about sending people back. We already send many people back, and the number of asylum seekers to Denmark is quite low.”

Instead, she emphasised: “For us, it is an opportunity to send some out, but the signal we are sending, that you can no longer travel illegally into the EU and believe that you can stay, is important.”

On Rwanda’s human rights record, she told TV 2, “When we enter into cooperation with other countries, we lay a foundation under it that is precisely respect for human rights and international law, and then we will also establish some form of mechanism that monitors that everything is as it should be.”

However, in an appearance on DR’s Deadline, she refused to rule out sending people to Rwanda even if people sent by Denmark were arrested for criticising the Rwandan government or were the victims of torture.

More stories